Do You Need a Merchant of Record to Sell Digital Products?

Two people stand at a shop counter, one handing a bank card to the other, with loose coins on the counter.

Do you need a merchant of record to sell digital products? Not automatically. You need one when the work of collecting and remitting tax across many borders costs more than the 5% to 10% cut a merchant of record takes. A merchant of record becomes the legal seller to your customer and handles VAT, GST and US sales tax for you. If you sell into a handful of jurisdictions, your own Stripe account plus your own registrations is usually cheaper.

TL;DR:

  • A merchant of record is the legal seller to your customer, so it takes on VAT, GST and sales tax registration and remittance.
  • It typically costs about 5% of gross revenue, and that cut scales as you grow while a fixed accounting bill does not.
  • At $10,000 a month, a 5% cut costs $6,000 a year against roughly $4,200 in Stripe fees on domestic cards.
  • Cross-border sales flip the math: Stripe adds 1.5% for international cards and 1% for currency conversion, which can push your effective rate past 5%.
  • Shopify and Stripe are not merchants of record. On both, you are the seller of record.

Table of Contents

Do You Need a Merchant of Record to Sell Digital Products? The Threshold Test

The number that decides this is how many tax jurisdictions your customers live in, and what your time costs.

A merchant of record earns its fee when three things are true at once. You sell directly to consumers in digital form. Your buyers are spread across many countries or many US states. And your monthly volume is low enough that a percentage cut costs less than the accounting work it replaces.

Take the reverse case. If 90% of your sales go to customers in one country, you might be looking at two or three tax registrations, not thirty. Handing over 5% of every sale forever to avoid three filings is a bad trade, and it gets worse every month you grow.

To place yourself on the right side of that line, you need four things: what a merchant of record actually does, what it costs, what you take on without one, and the revenue points where the answer flips. If you want the definition first, what a merchant of record is, explained in plain terms covers the mechanics before you compare prices.

What a Merchant of Record Actually Takes Off Your Plate

A merchant of record is the legal seller to your customer. It buys your product from you at wholesale and resells it to the buyer at retail, which means the sale on the receipt is theirs, not yours.

Duty Merchant of record You, with your own Stripe account
Legal seller to the customer The merchant of record You
Sales tax, VAT and GST collection Handled Yours
Tax registration and remittance Handled Yours
Chargebacks and disputes Usually absorbed Yours, plus a dispute fee
Refund handling Handled Yours
Payment processing Bundled into the fee Stripe's published rates
Invoice and receipt issuer Their name Your name
Cost Commonly around 5%, with some platforms charging 10% or more 2.9% plus 30 cents on domestic cards

That table is the whole trade. A merchant of record sells you tax compliance, dispute handling and a processing account as one bundle, priced as a percentage of gross revenue. You can buy those things separately, and at higher volume you usually should.

Two details matter more than the headline fee. The percentage comes off gross revenue, so it scales with growth while a fixed accounting bill does not. And most merchant-of-record contracts bundle processing, so you cannot stack a cheaper processor underneath them. If your name is on the invoice, the filing that follows is yours.

What States Require Sales Tax for Online Sales

For US sellers, the physical presence rule is gone. In South Dakota v. Wayfair, decided in 2018, the Supreme Court held that states can require remote sellers with no in-state presence to collect sales tax once they cross an economic threshold.

45 states and the District of Columbia levy a statewide sales tax. Alaska, Delaware, Montana, New Hampshire and Oregon do not.

The standard threshold is $100,000 in sales into a state during the current or previous calendar year. About half the states also count transactions, usually 200, and several have dropped that test since Wayfair. Missouri was the last state to adopt economic nexus, effective January 1, 2023, which closed the map.

Specific details worth knowing:

  • Kansas and Colorado. Kansas uses $100,000 with no transaction count. Colorado uses $100,000 but applies its home rule cities on top, a complication most summaries skip.
  • Marketplace sales. All 45 sales tax states now have marketplace facilitator laws, so a marketplace collects and remits on sales it processes. Your own website is still your problem.
  • Digital goods. States disagree about whether a downloaded file, a subscription or a SaaS seat is taxable. New York taxes prewritten software. Others exempt most electronically delivered products. Read your state's definition, because the wording decides the answer.

What You Take On Without a Merchant of Record

None of this is hard, but it is yours to do.

  • Registration. You register where you have nexus, which in the US means economic thresholds and in the EU means the customer's country. HMRC requires non-UK businesses selling digital services to UK consumers to register for VAT from their first sale, with no turnover threshold.
  • Remittance. The European Commission's One Stop Shop lets you file one VAT return covering all EU business-to-consumer digital sales. It applies once your cross-border sales pass €10,000 a year.
  • Invoicing. EU VAT invoices carry required fields: your VAT number, the customer's location, the rate applied and the amount in the customer's currency.
  • Disputes. You answer chargebacks. Stripe charges $15 per dispute on top of losing the sale, per its published pricing.
  • PCI scope. A hosted checkout page keeps you in SAQ A, the shortest self-assessment questionnaire. Collecting card fields on your own domain moves you to SAQ A-EP. The PCI Security Standards Council publishes both.
  • Consumer law. EU rules give buyers 14 days to withdraw from a digital purchase unless they expressly consent to immediate delivery and acknowledge losing that right.

Pro Tip: If your EU sales sit near the €10,000 threshold, model both sides of the line before you commit to anything annual. Below it you can charge your home country's VAT rate and file locally. Above it you switch to destination VAT through the One Stop Shop. A merchant of record makes the threshold irrelevant because it is the seller either way, so the fee you are weighing is the price of never thinking about that line again. Run the comparison over 12 months and count your hours, not just the filing fee.

Is Shopify a Merchant of Record?

No. On a Shopify store you are the seller of record. Shopify supplies the storefront, hosting and checkout, and if you use Shopify Payments it also processes the cards, but tax registration and remittance sit with you.

Two related questions follow.

  • Is Stripe a merchant of record? No. Stripe is a payment processor. Its tax product calculates rates and can file in some jurisdictions, but the legal liability stays with you.
  • Are marketplaces merchants of record? Often, yes, for the transaction. When a marketplace collects and remits sales tax under a facilitator law, it takes the seller-of-record position for that sale. That is why many marketplace sellers hold no sales tax permit of their own.

Seller of record and merchant of record are usually the same party. The seller of record is whoever is named on the transaction and owes the tax. A merchant of record is a seller of record that has taken on the full bundle: processing, refunds, disputes and filing. Some contracts split those roles, so check before you sign. If a platform calls itself your seller of record but leaves remittance to you, you have the liability without the service.

What To Do if an Online Shop Didn't Charge You Sales Tax

The answer depends on which side of the transaction you are on.

As a buyer: most states with a sales tax also levy a use tax on purchases where the seller did not collect. You owe it, and most states put a line for it on the individual income tax return. If you bought something expensive from an out-of-state seller that charged no tax, that line is where it goes.

As a seller: if you had nexus and did not collect, you owe the tax whether or not you collected it from the customer. Registering late means back taxes, interest and penalties, and states can look back several years.

Your options:

  • Register and file now. Stop the clock. Some states offer a limited lookback for first-time registrants who come forward voluntarily.
  • Apply for a voluntary disclosure agreement. A VDA typically limits the lookback to three or four years and waives penalties. The Multistate Tax Commission runs a National Nexus Program for sellers with exposure in several states at once.
  • Do nothing. The worst option. States cross-reference processor data and marketplace reports, and the assessment only grows.

Can You Resell Products Without a License?

It depends on what you are reselling and where you are.

  • Physical goods in the US. No federal license exists for reselling. You need a sales tax permit in each state where you have nexus, plus a resale certificate so your supplier does not charge you sales tax on inventory you intend to resell.
  • Someone else's digital product. You need written permission from the rights holder. That is a distribution or reseller agreement, and without one, reselling access to a course, template or software license is copyright infringement.
  • Your own digital product. No license needed to sell it. You still need the sales tax permit and any local business registration your city or state requires, and a marketplace may ask for a reseller certificate before it pays you.
  • Drop shipping. The resale certificate usually has to come from you, not your supplier, because you are the seller to the end customer.

The Math at Three Revenue Levels

Assume a $50 average order, domestic US cards, and a merchant of record charging 5%. Stripe's US rate is 2.9% plus 30 cents on a successful domestic charge.

Monthly sales Orders at $50 Merchant of record at 5% Stripe, domestic Difference per year
$1,000 20 $50 $35 $180
$10,000 200 $500 $350 $1,800
$50,000 1,000 $2,500 $1,750 $9,000

At $1,000 a month, the merchant-of-record premium is $180 a year. One state registration and a year of filing can easily cost more than that, so the bundle wins. At $50,000 a month you are paying $9,000 a year for compliance that probably costs less, and the case for owning your checkout gets strong.

Cross-border sales change the answer for one kind of seller.

Stripe charges 2.9% plus 30 cents on a domestic card, then adds 1.5% for an international card and another 1% for currency conversion. A cross-border sale can cost you 5.4% before any tax work.

If nearly all your sales are cross-border and in other currencies, Stripe's effective rate lands near or above what a merchant of record charges, and the merchant of record throws in the tax filing. At $50,000 a month of fully international sales, Stripe's cut would run about $3,000 against the merchant of record's $2,500. In that case the obvious answer is wrong and the bundle is cheaper. Run your own currency mix before you decide. The full comparison at three revenue levels goes deeper on where the break-even sits.

Keep Your Stripe Account and Stop Paying a Per-Sale Cut

A person at a wooden desk with a closed laptop, a dark card reader, and a small stack of coins under one hand.

ReplaPay sells a self-hosted checkout license for a one-time $299. You connect your own Stripe account, take card and crypto payments through payment links, and keep the difference on every sale. At $10,000 a month, moving off a 5% merchant-of-record cut saves $1,800 a year against a one-time $299 license. If you are already selling through a marketplace-style checkout, the math on direct Stripe integration versus marketplace checkout shows where your break-even sits.

One caveat matters. ReplaPay does not make you a merchant of record. Tax registration, VAT returns and sales tax remittance stay with you, and so do chargebacks. Crypto payments settle straight to your wallet and cannot be reversed, so a refund on a crypto order is yours to solve. The license includes 12 months of updates and 30 days of setup support, and after that updates are optional. Check the spec sheet before you buy, including ours, and confirm your Stripe account handles the currencies and card types you actually need. If most of your sales are cross-border, price Stripe's international and conversion fees first. The step-by-step setup guide walks through the Stripe connection.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need a merchant of record to sell digital products?

Only if the tax and compliance work of selling into many jurisdictions costs more than the percentage cut. Sellers concentrated in one or two countries usually come out ahead with their own Stripe account and their own registrations. Sellers with customers spread across twenty countries often do not.

Is Shopify a merchant of record?

No. On a Shopify store you are the seller of record and you owe the sales tax registration and remittance. Shopify Payments handles card processing, which is a different job from being the legal seller to your customer.

What states require sales tax for online sales?

Forty-five states plus the District of Columbia levy a statewide sales tax, and each of those states requires remote sellers to collect once they pass an economic nexus threshold, usually $100,000 in sales. Alaska, Delaware, Montana, New Hampshire and Oregon have no statewide sales tax.

What do I do if an online shop didn't charge me sales tax?

As a buyer, you likely owe use tax to your state and can report it on your individual income tax return. As a seller, you owe the uncollected tax yourself plus interest and penalties, and a voluntary disclosure agreement is often the cheapest way to fix several years of missed filings.

Can I resell products without a license?

Reselling physical goods in the US needs no federal license, but you need a sales tax permit where you have nexus and a resale certificate for your supplier. Reselling someone else's digital product requires written permission from the rights holder, or it is copyright infringement.

Is Stripe a merchant of record?

No, Stripe is a payment processor. Its tax product calculates rates and can file in some jurisdictions, but the legal liability for collecting and remitting stays with you, not Stripe.

Sources